My first pick is the 1972 Miami Dolphins. They lost their starting quarterback during the season, led the league in points scored and points allowed, and won their last game. If the question were which team I would take for one afternoon on a fast field, the 1989 49ers might get my vote. Those are two different ballots.
For this one, the unit of comparison is one NFL season. A dynasty cannot borrow the best traits of five different championship teams. I give the most weight to what a team did against its contemporaries, then to how it finished and how many ways it could win when an opponent took away its first choice.
1. 1972 Miami Dolphins
Miami went 14-0 in the regular season and won three postseason games. Earl Morrall kept the offense moving while Bob Griese recovered from injury. Larry Csonka and Mercury Morris both cleared 1,000 yards, a remarkable concentration of rushing production in a 14-game schedule. A crowded box made Paul Warfield more dangerous on the possessions when Miami chose to throw.
The strongest argument against Miami is the shorter schedule. The strongest argument for it is that few great teams have been tested by the loss of their starting quarterback and continued winning every week. Their three playoff victories came by a combined 17 points. They had to execute with the outcome still in doubt.
2. 1985 Chicago Bears
Chicago went 15-1 in the regular season. Its postseason opponents scored ten points combined, all in the Super Bowl. In the divisional round and conference championship game, holding the Giants and Rams to zero made any offensive contribution by Walter Payton’s unit a problem the opponent could hardly solve.
I put Chicago second because its best weapon could dictate how the other quarterback played from the opening snap. The 38-24 loss in Miami is part of the evaluation. A passer with a quick release and receivers who could uncover on time had a route around the rush. Most teams never found it.
3. 1989 San Francisco 49ers
San Francisco’s postseason scores tell the story in three lines. It beat Minnesota 41-13, the Rams 30-3 and Denver 55-10. That is 126 points scored and 26 allowed. An offense with Joe Montana, Jerry Rice and Roger Craig could make the wrong defensive choice look obvious a second after the snap.
Craig is the player I would study to understand why this team travels well across eras. Leaving a linebacker on him gave Montana a passing matchup. Replacing that linebacker with a defensive back created an opportunity to run. The 49ers could ask the same question from the same group of eleven and accept either answer.
4. 1991 Washington
Washington finished 14-2, then beat Atlanta, Detroit and Buffalo in the playoffs. Against the Bills in Super Bowl XXVI, Washington took away the early scoring its opponent needed to dictate pace, then put the game away behind Mark Rypien. The final was 37-24.
This is the team I would give a coach who wants an ordinary first down to feel easy. Its line could protect long enough for Rypien to attack downfield, and the receivers made it expensive to add another defender to the run fit. Its roster had answers for such different opponents that it is easy to overlook just how little drama accompanied much of the season.
5. 1978 Pittsburgh Steelers
Pittsburgh beat Dallas 35-31 for the title after a 14-2 regular season. The defense gave Terry Bradshaw room to take chances, and Lynn Swann and John Stallworth made defensive backs pay for selling out against Franco Harris. This edition of the Steel Curtain could also win a championship game that turned into a scoring race.
There are fair alternatives here. The 1984 49ers and 1976 Raiders have championship cases of their own. I choose Pittsburgh for the breadth of things an opponent had to prepare for on both sides of the ball.
Where do the 2007 Patriots belong?
For regular-season performance alone, put them in the opening argument. New England went 16-0 and scored 589 points. It then reached 18-0 before losing 17-14 to the Giants in Super Bowl XLII. My ranking gives the championship enough weight to keep New England outside these five. A ranking of the most difficult offenses to defend could quite reasonably put it first.
Building an all-time team by franchise changes the question again. You can give the Steelers from one decade help from a different generation. Pick the weakness in your favorite historical team and spend your first legends pick on the player who would have fixed it.
All-time NFL teams by franchise
Which players would make your own team better? Each franchise board ranks its legends and lays out the offensive and defensive selections. Start with your division, then look at the other side of a rivalry.
- AFC East Buffalo Bills · Miami Dolphins · New England Patriots · New York Jets
- NFC East Dallas Cowboys · New York Giants · Philadelphia Eagles · Washington Commanders
- AFC North Baltimore Ravens · Cincinnati Bengals · Cleveland Browns · Pittsburgh Steelers
- NFC North Chicago Bears · Detroit Lions · Green Bay Packers · Minnesota Vikings
- AFC South Houston Texans · Indianapolis Colts · Jacksonville Jaguars · Tennessee Titans
- NFC South Atlanta Falcons · Carolina Panthers · New Orleans Saints · Tampa Bay Buccaneers
- AFC West Denver Broncos · Kansas City Chiefs · Las Vegas Raiders · Los Angeles Chargers
- NFC West Arizona Cardinals · Los Angeles Rams · San Francisco 49ers · Seattle Seahawks
Draft your own candidate for the greatest team ever
