Cleveland gives us a running back who finished eight of his nine NFL seasons as the rushing leader and a quarterback whose teams reached a championship game in ten consecutive seasons. Pick your measure carelessly and one of those men disappears. We count the Browns’ AAFC years, distinguish those championships from NFL titles, and follow the club’s official Cleveland history through the interruption of the 1990s. Our order rewards what a player did in Cleveland and how much of a game plan he could carry.
1. Jim Brown, running back
Brown rushed for 12,312 yards in nine seasons. He could stay on his feet through a square hit and run away from the safety who should have benefited from it. That combination lets a coordinator call the same inside run a second time after the defense has adjusted. Few players have ever reduced the need for disguise so convincingly.
2. Otto Graham, quarterback
Graham led Cleveland to four AAFC championships and three NFL titles. Movement was part of the design: he could threaten the edge himself or hold the ball until a receiver uncovered behind a defender who stepped up. The Browns’ immediate NFL title in 1950 is valuable evidence for anyone tempted to dismiss the first half of his career.
3. Joe Thomas, left tackle
Thomas played 10,363 consecutive offensive snaps before an injury ended the streak. The roster around him changed so frequently that his best work rarely came with national attention. Judge the tackle’s actual job: surviving an isolated pass rush. He performed it long enough for Cleveland to plan practically a decade of protections around his side.
4. Myles Garrett, defensive end
Garrett’s first step can force a tackle to open his hips early, which gives the rusher a path back inside. His value extends to the receiver whose route must wait while the tight end helps the protection. He is the first Cleveland defender we would select against a contemporary opponent that lives in three-wide personnel.
5. Lou Groza, tackle and kicker
Groza made the offense better between kicks. He played offensive tackle on championship teams and also extended the distance from which a possession could produce points. Field-goal ranges and league conditions changed, so we credit how much his kicking altered Cleveland’s choices in his own time.
6. Ozzie Newsome, tight end
Newsome caught 662 regular-season passes for the Browns. A reliable receiver at tight end gives a quarterback an option in the middle without requiring a receiver substitution. That is particularly valuable with Brown in the backfield: the defense must keep enough size to stop the run while covering a gifted route runner between the hashes.
7. Marion Motley, fullback
Motley was both a punishing runner and a protector for Graham. His role in reintegrating professional football also required playing through conditions modern players do not face. On this roster his blocking allows Brown to attack the edge and his own carrying makes a two-back look dangerous in either direction.
How much room is there for another running back?
Leroy Kelly is the outstanding argument left on the bench. He succeeded Brown and produced two NFL rushing titles of his own. We take Motley for a two-back offense because the tasks divide more cleanly. Give the roster a single backup ball carrier and Kelly’s acceleration makes the decision much closer. On defense, Bill Willis deserves the same cross-era consideration for what his quickness at middle guard made possible.
An all-time Browns draft roster
Offensive selections QB Otto Graham, RB Jim Brown, WRs Paul Warfield and Dante Lavelli, TE Ozzie Newsome. Build the line around Joe Thomas, Gene Hickerson and Frank Gatski. Marion Motley leads the two-back package.
Defensive selections Myles Garrett rushes outside and Bill Willis attacks inside. Clay Matthews Jr. leads the linebackers, with Frank Minnifield and Hanford Dixon at corner. Thom Darden patrols the deep middle.
Build a 17-0 team in FSN All-Timers
Follow Cleveland Browns coverage on FSN.
Explore all 32 franchise draft boards and FSN’s greatest NFL teams.
