Dallas can build a great team twice, once with the players who made the star a national attraction and again with the group that won three championships in four seasons. The hard part is deciding where those teams meet. We start with the quarterback who most expands a broken play, choose a back who can keep that play on schedule in the first place, and leave enough room for the defenders who carried Dallas before the triplets arrived.
1. Roger Staubach, quarterback
Staubach supplied two plays for the price of one. Dallas could run a disciplined first progression, then still threaten a deep throw after the protection broke down. The two championships matter, but his fit with this roster matters too. A receiver like Michael Irvin can work back to him while Bob Hayes occupies a safety far downfield.
2. Emmitt Smith, running back
Of his NFL rushing yards, 17,162 came as a Cowboy. His patience makes an all-time line more than an assembly of great blockers: let Larry Allen establish leverage, wait for the linebacker to commit, then take the crease before it closes. On third down he also knew which rusher the protection had left for the back.
3. Bob Lilly, defensive tackle
Dallas built the early Doomsday defense around pressure from inside. A quarterback who can step up can usually survive an edge rusher. Lilly took that step away. His long pursuit on a running play also closed a route that normally belongs to a linebacker. That second responsibility separates him from a pure passing-down specialist.
4. Larry Allen, guard
Allen could move a defender who had already set his feet, then run well enough to lead a back through the next gap. He also played tackle when Dallas needed him to. At left guard for this team, his power lets us spend our other premium picks on receiving talent instead of adding another blocker to each formation.
5. Randy White, defensive tackle
White gives Dallas a second great interior defender with a different route to the ball. A former linebacker, he could attack a gap and pursue once the run bounced away. Put him next to Lilly and the center’s first decision becomes one of the opponent’s most important calls.
6. Troy Aikman, quarterback
Aikman gets the start if the assignment is to recreate the 1990s Cowboys precisely. His accuracy on an intermediate route gave Irvin a chance to finish the catch and protect himself against contact. With Smith carrying so much of the offense, a smaller passing volume tells us little about how difficult those crucial throws were.
7. Michael Irvin, wide receiver
Dallas could run its timing routes even when the corner recognized them because Irvin was so difficult to move off his spot. The slant and the deep in-cut give a quarterback two different ways to attack a defense sitting on Smith. He is the first Cowboy selected to move the chains on third-and-seven.
8. Mel Renfro, defensive back
Renfro earns the final spot on the core board for his flexibility. He could handle safety responsibilities or isolate outside at corner, exceptionally valuable when selecting defensive backs from different periods. Darren Woodson can do the physical work closer to the line while Renfro handles space.
Where do Dorsett, Witten and the pass rush fit?
Tony Dorsett gives Dallas a long-distance threat that Smith’s patient inside style does not emphasize. Jason Witten caught 1,215 regular-season passes for the Cowboys, making him the easy tight-end choice. DeMarcus Ware and Harvey Martin are our edge pairing. The narrowest cut on defense is Chuck Howley, a linebacker who could cover enough ground to play against a modern passing attack and belongs on the field in the base group.
An all-time Cowboys draft roster
Offensive selections QB Roger Staubach, RB Emmitt Smith, WRs Michael Irvin, Drew Pearson and Bob Hayes, TE Jason Witten. LT Tyron Smith, LG Larry Allen, C Travis Frederick, RG Zack Martin, RT Rayfield Wright.
Defensive selections DEs DeMarcus Ware and Harvey Martin, DTs Bob Lilly and Randy White. Chuck Howley and Lee Roy Jordan play linebacker. The five defensive backs are Mel Renfro, Everson Walls, Cornell Green, Cliff Harris and Darren Woodson.
Build a 17-0 team in FSN All-Timers
Follow Dallas Cowboys coverage on FSN.
Explore all 32 franchise draft boards and FSN’s greatest NFL teams.
