One roster slot buys Washington a starting quarterback and a punter. In the right personnel group it can buy a defensive back, too. Sammy Baugh asks a question that a modern depth chart rarely has to answer. How much credit does a player get for changing jobs before his teammates have even left the field?
This ranking counts the full franchise history under its various names. Our board rewards dominance relative to contemporaries, sustained performance in Washington and the job each player gives an all-time lineup. That leaves plenty of room for a modern specialist to challenge a two-way pioneer.
1. Sammy Baugh, quarterback, defensive back and punter
Baugh led the NFL in passing, punting and defensive interceptions in 1943. The shorthand barely captures the difficulty. Facing the other way after a change of possession meant making reads against an entirely different eleven. He starts at quarterback and handles punting for our team, with his defensive work reserved for an emergency.
2. Darrell Green, cornerback
Green played twenty seasons for Washington. His speed is easiest to appreciate on a play that appears to be over. A receiver with a step still had to finish the route and catch the pass before Green could close. A coordinator could shade help away from him and devote it to the messier side of the formation.
3. Charley Taylor, receiver and running back
Taylor began as a running back and became a Hall of Fame receiver. For a quarterback that combination turns an ordinary short completion into a chance to gain another first down. It also gives the offense a way to move the same player between the backfield and the formation’s widest point.
4. Art Monk, wide receiver
Monk caught 106 passes in 1984. His role on this offense is the route that crosses the first-down marker with a corner close enough to contest the catch. Play him inside Taylor and the defense must decide which receiver its most physical cover man can follow.
5. John Riggins, running back
On fourth-and-one in Super Bowl XVII, Riggins turned a conversion attempt into a 43-yard touchdown. An opponent knew Washington’s strength and still had to defeat the blocks and finish the tackle. That makes him a remarkably easy selection for a particular down and distance.
6. Russ Grimm, guard
The most persuasive argument for drafting one of the Hogs is the number of different backs and quarterbacks who benefited from that line. Grimm gives this group a left guard who can move a defender in tight space. On the Riggins play, the yards after contact still required a first lane to run through.
7. Chris Hanburger, linebacker
Hanburger earned nine Pro Bowl selections as a Washington linebacker. He gives the front seven a player who can diagnose the play and pass the adjustment along. That is a valuable complement to edge rushers who want to attack the moment the ball moves.
Which Washington quarterback gets the two-minute drive?
Baugh gets the first series on historical influence and the number of jobs he solves. Sonny Jurgensen has the strongest claim if the assignment is strictly to throw against a modern secondary. Joe Theismann offers mobility, and Doug Williams has the most memorable quarter of championship passing in franchise history. With one timeout at midfield, I would send in Jurgensen, put Monk in the slot and leave Taylor outside. On fourth-and-one, I would keep the same receivers wide and put Riggins behind Grimm and Joe Jacoby.
An all-time Commanders draft roster
Offensive selections QB Sammy Baugh, RB John Riggins, WRs Charley Taylor, Art Monk and Gary Clark, TE Jerry Smith. Chris Samuels and Joe Jacoby take the tackle spots, with Russ Grimm, Jeff Bostic and Brandon Scherff inside.
Defensive selections Dexter Manley, Dave Butz, Diron Talbert and Charles Mann play up front. Assign Chris Hanburger, London Fletcher and Sam Huff to the second level. Darrell Green and Pat Fischer take the corners, with Ken Houston and Sean Taylor at safety.
Build a 17-0 team in FSN All-Timers
Follow Washington Commanders coverage on FSN.
Explore all 32 franchise draft boards and FSN’s greatest NFL teams.
