Try the quarterback debate backward. Give Joe Montana a receiving group without Jerry Rice, then give Steve Young the same assignment. Both remain exceptional selections. Give Rice almost any competent passer in franchise history and the entire passing game changes. That is why we choose the receiver first. This San Francisco ranking weighs sustained 49ers work, peak against contemporaries and how reliably the player’s best football could survive championship-level preparation.
1. Jerry Rice, wide receiver
Rice could make the first ten yards of two routes look alike, forcing a defender to commit before the break. Once the catch came, the play often had another gain left in it. His 49ers career spans championships with Montana and Young, which matters because the offense around him did change. The certainty of getting open remained.
2. Joe Montana, quarterback
Montana was unusually comfortable delivering a small gain when the defense had taken the deeper route. Then, once a safety cheated forward, he could make the big throw with the same release. His four Super Bowl victories with San Francisco came in offenses with different receiving groups. The first two preceded Rice’s arrival.
3. Ronnie Lott, defensive back
Lott could start a career at corner and become an elite safety without losing the ability to read a receiver outside. On this roster we want him at safety, where a quarterback moving off Rice’s counterpart still has one more defender to locate. His versatility also rescues the defense if an early draft pick at corner is unavailable.
4. Steve Young, quarterback
Young combines a passer’s command of the quick game with a running threat that changes the edge defender’s assignment. In Super Bowl XXIX he threw six touchdown passes. The most dangerous part of starting him may be how little the rest of the playbook needs to change when the defense decides to contain the run.
5. Bob St. Clair, tackle
St. Clair supplies size and movement to an offensive line that predates the famous West Coast teams. The Million Dollar Backfield had to have a path to the second level. It did not manufacture every hole by itself. His inclusion recognizes a football task that remains almost unchanged across formations: secure the edge long enough for the back to choose.
6. Patrick Willis, linebacker
Willis could meet a runner in a tight gap and still cover enough ground to play against a spread formation. That makes him the first linebacker on this board and avoids an immediate substitution whenever the opponent changes its personnel. His ability to finish a tackle in space is a particularly good complement to an aggressive secondary.
7. Terrell Owens, wide receiver
Owens gives the offense a receiver who can win after contact when a defense has already tackled the route correctly. His late touchdown catch against Green Bay after the 1998 season is the high-pressure example. On a unit already stocked with precision routes, his size adds a different physical problem on the opposite boundary.
Why no single lineup settles the 49ers’ running back question
Frank Gore earns the primary job for a full season. Roger Craig gives a two-back set its most interesting dimension: in 1985 he reached 1,000 yards both rushing and receiving. Joe Perry offers another style from a much earlier era. Take Craig first if short passing is central to your plan, then watch whether the opponent chooses a linebacker or a defensive back to follow him out of the formation.
An all-time 49ers draft roster
Offensive selections QB Joe Montana, RB Frank Gore, WRs Jerry Rice and Terrell Owens, TE George Kittle. Bob St. Clair and Joe Staley take the tackle spots. Roger Craig moves between the backfield and the slot.
Defensive selections Charles Haley rushes the edge, Bryant Young and Leo Nomellini attack inside, and Patrick Willis handles the middle. Jimmy Johnson takes the top corner assignment with Ronnie Lott at safety.
Build a 17-0 team in FSN All-Timers
Follow San Francisco 49ers coverage on FSN.
Explore all 32 franchise draft boards and FSN’s greatest NFL teams.
