Green Bay has three quarterbacks a reasonable fan could put first. That creates an opportunity: take the receiver who was farthest ahead of his contemporaries, let the quarterbacks fall where they may, and still walk away with a great one. Our Packers ranking looks at the advantage a player created in his own era, how much of it came in Green Bay and what would carry into an all-time lineup. It starts before the Lombardi years.
1. Don Hutson, end
Hutson retired with 99 touchdown receptions when throwing the ball was still an occasional choice for many offenses. The defense had to account for his route before it could commit to the run. We give him the first pick because the gap between what he could do and what opponents were equipped to cover was so large.
2. Aaron Rodgers, quarterback
Rodgers’ 2011 MVP season paired 45 touchdown passes with six interceptions. Deep throws usually cost a quarterback some control over turnovers. That season he combined aggression with extraordinary ball security. If our receivers win outside, we want the passer able to attack both boundaries without regularly asking his defense to bail him out.
3. Brett Favre, quarterback
Favre won three consecutive league MVP awards, sharing the last with Barry Sanders. He generated throws after the original route had broken down and could take a physical beating without surrendering the huddle. His 61,655 Green Bay passing yards represent a much longer run of useful football than any single risk-taking highlight can explain.
4. Bart Starr, quarterback
Starr won five NFL championships as Green Bay’s starter, including the first two Super Bowls. The quarterback sneak in the Ice Bowl gets remembered as a test of nerve. It was also sound football judgment: under the conditions, the short path behind his center and guard offered the best chance. He is our choice for the Lombardi offense in its original form.
5. Forrest Gregg, tackle
The power sweep asks the moving guards to get the attention, but the perimeter of the line still has to hold together while they go. Gregg had the feet and balance to secure his part of the play and protect Starr when the run action gave way to a pass. He would start on our right side regardless of quarterback.
6. Ray Nitschke, middle linebacker
Green Bay trusted Nitschke to handle runs between the tackles without becoming a liability when the offense threw over the middle. He could arrive hard and still play with control over the gap. A mixed-era defense needs somebody to make the crowded snaps predictable for the players around him.
7. Reggie White, defensive end
His Philadelphia seasons earn no points on this board. His three sacks against New England in Super Bowl XXXI are ample evidence of what Green Bay acquired. White could pressure the passer while playing strong enough to stay on the edge against the run. The defense did not need to substitute to obtain both jobs.
8. Jim Taylor, fullback
The sweep needed a back who would press toward the blocks, let the defenders commit and still finish a run through contact. Taylor did that work and won the 1962 league MVP award. A modern roster can use him as its main runner or pair him with Paul Hornung. In both cases the center of the defense has to take the threat seriously.
Where do the guards and defensive backs fit?
Jerry Kramer and Fuzzy Thurston get the first invitation to pull for Taylor. Sterling Sharpe earns an outside receiving spot opposite Hutson. Davante Adams can move inside or beat the opponent’s best press corner from the boundary. The secondary is the toughest unit to keep to four names. Herb Adderley supplies dependable outside coverage, Charles Woodson can move around, and Willie Wood gives the defense a true deep safety.
An all-time Packers draft roster
Offensive selections QB Aaron Rodgers, RB Jim Taylor, WRs Don Hutson, Sterling Sharpe and Davante Adams, TE Ron Kramer. LT David Bakhtiari, LG Fuzzy Thurston, C Jim Ringo, RG Jerry Kramer, RT Forrest Gregg.
Defensive selections DEs Reggie White and Willie Davis, DTs Henry Jordan and Gilbert Brown. Ray Nitschke, Dave Robinson and Clay Matthews at linebacker. Herb Adderley and Charles Woodson at corner, Willie Wood and LeRoy Butler at safety.
Build a 17-0 team in FSN All-Timers
Follow Green Bay Packers coverage on FSN.
Explore all 32 franchise draft boards and FSN’s greatest NFL teams.
