If Pittsburgh could take one player from its history into a game tomorrow, taking a quarterback would be the sensible answer in almost any other city. Here the first pick is a defensive tackle. Put Joe Greene on the field and the other team has a problem before the quarterback gets to look downfield. The center needs help. A guard who might otherwise climb to Jack Lambert has to stay put. The linebackers get a cleaner picture. One selection improves three positions.
That is how FSN weighed Pittsburghâs best players: excellence relative to the playerâs own era, how long that excellence lasted in Pittsburgh, and what changed on the field when the opponent knew exactly whom it had to stop. Championships matter most when you can point to something the player did to win them. These are the 15 careers we would build around, followed by the starting lineup we would actually send out.
1. Joe Greene, defensive tackle
In Super Bowl IX, Greene recovered a fumble and intercepted a pass. Minnesota had to deal with him in the running game, then lost a possession to him on a passing play. The lasting advantage was less visible: the Steelers could disrupt the pocket from a four-man front and still leave seven men available to cover. Greene earns first choice because his best football gave Pittsburgh so many choices about everybody else.
2. Mel Blount, cornerback
Put Blount over the opponentâs largest receiver and watch how little help he needs. His length and strength made a clean release expensive, and his 11 interceptions in 1975 punished quarterbacks who challenged him anyway. When the league restricted contact downfield in 1978, he remained an effective corner on two more championship teams. That second act matters in a draft that asks him to play across eras.
3. Jack Lambert, middle linebacker
The popular picture is Lambert standing over somebody. The more instructive one is Lambert retreating from the line after the snap, taking away a throw over the middle. A defense with Greene up front could afford a middle linebacker who ran that well. Pair the two and an offense has to account for the same defender on an inside handoff and on the tight endâs route behind it.
Who gets your first pick against Oakland? Build a Steelers-led roster from different eras and take on the 1976 Raiders in a one-game rematch.
Draft a Steelers-led team against the 1976 Raiders
4. Troy Polamalu, safety
With Baltimore down two late in the 2008 AFC championship game, Polamalu read Joe Flacco, cut across the throwing lane and returned the interception 40 yards for a touchdown. It explains why a quarterback had to find him twice: once before the snap and again before releasing the ball. A secondary with dependable corners could give him that freedom. Pittsburgh has the corners to do it here.
5. Jack Ham, outside linebacker
Ham is our choice if the opponent sends a running back into the route on third down. He could follow the back, take away the outlet or beat the block if the play came back inside. An outside linebacker able to do all three let Pittsburgh keep its regular personnel on the field longer. His case gains ground as soon as you start writing down assignments.
6. Mike Webster, center
The quarterback gets to change the play. Somebody still has to tell the line where the pressure is coming from. Webster gave Pittsburgh that organizer and a remarkably strong point of attack. His career ran through the transition from Franco Harris carrying the offense to Terry Bradshaw pushing the ball downfield. On an all-time line drawn from different decades, that combination of communication and leverage is a first-order need.
7. Rod Woodson, cornerback
Count the Pittsburgh years on their own. Woodson intercepted 38 passes as a Steeler, could carry a fast receiver downfield and gave the return game a scoring threat. His later work at safety elsewhere is unnecessary to the argument. Opposite Blount, he gives this lineup a different kind of corner: dangerous playing off the receiver, watching the release and driving forward on the ball.
8. Terry Bradshaw, quarterback
Bradshaw gets the narrowest positional decision on this list. The deciding evidence comes late in his championship run, when the passing game increasingly had to finish the job. He won the MVP awards in Super Bowls XIII and XIV. With Lynn Swann and John Stallworth available, he was willing to throw into windows that only opened once the ball was in the air.
9. Ben Roethlisberger, quarterback
On an improvised third-and-long, he would be our first choice. Roethlisberger could shed the first rusher and give a broken route time to become a good one. The winning pass to Santonio Holmes in Super Bowl XLIII also showed what he could do on schedule: deliver over defenders to the one patch of end zone the receiver could still reach. His much larger passing workload makes this a real debate.
10. Franco Harris, running back
The Immaculate Reception invites people to remember one alert act in open space. The stronger case is how often Harris kept an entire offense on schedule. He could press inside behind a fullback, wait for the crease and still have speed once he reached the secondary. His 158 rushing yards in Super Bowl IX gave Pittsburgh the sustained offense it needed in a low-scoring first championship.
11. T.J. Watt, edge rusher
Watt tied the official single-season sack record of 22½ in 2021. Building a defense around him means giving the right tackle another problem besides speed around the corner: Watt attacks the ball as the quarterback begins to throw. He earns a place ahead of several decorated predecessors because his peak gives a defense a way to take possession on a down when a simple stop would already be a win.
12. Dermontti Dawson, center
Pittsburgh has a second center who would start for most franchises. Dawson could snap the ball, get out into space and beat a linebacker to the spot where the run was headed. A team leaning heavily on movement and outside runs might choose him over Webster. Here we take Webster for the base offense and Dawson as the single toughest omission from the starting line.
13. John Stallworth, wide receiver
Stallworth gives Bradshaw room to throw long without asking the ball to land perfectly. In Super Bowl XIV his 73-yard touchdown put Pittsburgh back ahead of the Rams in the fourth quarter. He could win the route early and still finish through the catch, a useful distinction when a quarterback has to release before the receiver turns his head.
14. Hines Ward, wide receiver
Ward caught 1,000 regular-season passes for Pittsburgh. The all-time lineup needs his work on the downs when the ball goes elsewhere, too. Motion him across the formation and he can sell a run block, seal a defender on the perimeter or settle into a short passing window. He is the first receiver we would bring on for a third-and-four against a defense showing pressure.
15. Donnie Shell, safety
Shell is the second safety because his assignments fit beside Polamaluâs. He could close downhill on a runner and still had the hands to finish a passing play. He intercepted 51 regular-season passes. The same player can handle the conservative call when Pittsburgh has a lead and the aggressive one when an extra body is needed near the line.
Which Steelers linebacker, running back or receiver comes off the board first?
Lambert gets the first linebacker spot because he directs the middle. Against a spread team, Ham might be the more important matchup. James Harrison gets the other edge opposite Watt on obvious passing downs. At running back, Jerome Bettis is the short-yardage alternative to Harris, while a team committed to throwing to its back would have good reason to consider LeâVeon Bell. Those are different jobs, and Pittsburgh has an exceptional candidate for each.
Receiver is the position where the starting lineup departs most from the ranking. In a three-receiver set we want Stallworth on one boundary, Swann on the other and Ward able to move inside. Antonio Brown has a strong case to take either outside spot on the strength of his Pittsburgh receiving peak. We chose Swannâs ability to play a contested ball downfield for this particular Bradshaw-led offense.
An all-time Steelers starting lineup
Offense Terry Bradshaw starts at quarterback with Franco Harris behind him. John Stallworth, Lynn Swann and Hines Ward are the receivers, with Heath Miller at tight end. From left to right, the linemen are Jon Kolb, Alan Faneca, Mike Webster, David DeCastro and Tunch Ilkin.
Defense Aaron Smith, Casey Hampton and Joe Greene form a three-man front. T.J. Watt and James Harrison play outside linebacker. Jack Lambert and Jack Ham play inside, with Ham able to widen into coverage. Mel Blount and Rod Woodson take the corners, with Troy Polamalu and Donnie Shell at safety. Hamâs inside alignment is our cross-era projection.
Draft NFL legends and play a full season for 17-0
Follow Pittsburgh Steelers coverage on FSN.
Explore all 32 franchise draft boards and FSNâs greatest NFL teams.
