On third-and-two, Carolina’s all-time team can put a middle linebacker on the field who often knew the play before the snap, or a quarterback who made knowing the play insufficient. Luke Kuechly and Cam Newton illustrate why this is a closer board than a simple count of touchdowns or tackles suggests. We value a player’s Carolina years, his best sustained stretch and how much of the opponent’s plan had to change because he was there.
1. Luke Kuechly, middle linebacker
Kuechly could slip into the runner’s path before the guard arrived, then carry a route through the middle of the field on the next play. His interception returns for touchdowns in consecutive playoff games after the 2015 season show the scoring value of that anticipation. He is the first Panther we would hand a new defense to.
2. Julius Peppers, defensive end
Protection has to slide somewhere, and Peppers could punish it if the center guessed wrong. He had the reach to keep a tackle off his body and the agility to close from an angle that appeared safe. Both Carolina stints count here. His production for Chicago and Green Bay belongs to their draft boards.
3. Cam Newton, quarterback
The 2015 MVP threw 35 touchdown passes and ran for 10 scores. On short yardage, a defense accounting for the running back still had to tackle a quarterback with a fullback’s frame. Our offense gives him a receiver who can beat a corner on his own, so loading the box carries a price outside.
4. Steve Smith Sr., wide receiver
Smith caught 832 passes as a Panther. His most useful trick was playing a ball in the air like a much bigger receiver, then getting upfield like a returner. He keeps the offense from having to win every route with scheme. Against single coverage Newton can give him a competitive ball and turn to the next matchup.
5. Jordan Gross, offensive tackle
Gross could start on either side, a useful quality for a club that reached Super Bowls with very different styles across its history. On our roster he starts on the left. The opportunity cost of passing on a tackle is having to hold a tight end in protection, and we want Greg Olsen out running routes.
6. Thomas Davis, linebacker
Davis gives Kuechly a partner who can chase a play to the boundary and cover a back without forcing a change of personnel. The partnership has more than theoretical appeal. Their ability to exchange responsibilities made the defense harder to read, especially when the opponent went to play-action.
7. Greg Olsen, tight end
Three straight 1,000-yard receiving seasons for Carolina showed what a tight end could do as the reliable middle target in Newton’s offense. Split him away from the line and a linebacker has to show his intentions. Leave him attached and the defense still has to respect the quarterback run.
The argument for a different first pick
Peppers would lead this list on a roster with a serviceable middle linebacker and no pass rush. Smith would go first for a team desperate to win against man coverage. Christian McCaffrey offers another possibility: his 1,000-yard rushing and receiving season in 2019 gives a short-handed offense an entire package in one player. Our order assumes a fresh draft, where Kuechly can influence every defensive snap.
An all-time Panthers draft roster
Offensive selections QB Cam Newton, RB Christian McCaffrey, WRs Steve Smith and Muhsin Muhammad, TE Greg Olsen. LT Jordan Gross and C Ryan Kalil anchor the line. Jonathan Stewart supplies short-yardage power.
Defensive selections Julius Peppers and Charles Johnson rush the edges, Kris Jenkins takes the interior, Luke Kuechly and Thomas Davis work behind them. Chris Gamble and Josh Norman are the corners.
Build a 17-0 team in FSN All-Timers
Follow Carolina Panthers coverage on FSN.
Explore all 32 franchise draft boards and FSN’s greatest NFL teams.
