Buffalo’s all-time team should be able to run three different plays without letting the defense substitute. Thurman Thomas made that possible for Jim Kelly. Josh Allen adds another decision for the defense on every snap. Neither quarterback quite gets our first pick. That goes to the player who could wreck a rival’s passing game even when he was the only serious threat on his side of the line. We ranked work done for Buffalo, giving both the AFL champions and the four straight AFC champions their place.
1. Bruce Smith, defensive end
Smith became the NFL’s first player to reach 200 official sacks, with 171 of them coming for Buffalo. A 3–4 end is often expected to occupy a tackle so someone else can come free. Smith could do that job and still beat his own man. He gives this roster production at two assignments for the cost of one.
2. Josh Allen, quarterback
At the goal line Allen forces a defense to count the quarterback as a runner after it has already accounted for the back. Between the twenties his arm lets a receiver keep a route alive across the field. The 2024 MVP takes our starting job on the strength of those two options. Kelly has the stronger case for running the original offense exactly as drawn.
3. Thurman Thomas, running back
Thomas rushed for 11,938 yards with Buffalo and was dangerous enough as a receiver to split wide. Kelly could identify a linebacker following him out of the box, then use that information to change the call. Thomas is the player on this board whose mere movement before the snap tells the quarterback the most.
4. Jim Kelly, quarterback
Kelly’s distinctive strength was deciding what to run against the personnel already trapped on the field. His 35,467 passing yards in Buffalo came with the job of managing that tempo. If the opponent has a deep rotation of pass rushers, there is a compelling reason to take Kelly and stop them from rotating at all.
5. O.J. Simpson, running back
His 2,003 rushing yards in 1973 came in 14 games. The rushing average per game is the comparison that survives a changing schedule. Simpson is our first choice if the assignment is simply to carry the running game. Thomas edges him for an offense that wants the same group to spread out on third down.
6. Andre Reed, wide receiver
Reed caught 941 regular-season passes for the Bills. Crossing the middle at speed demanded both timing with Kelly and the balance to turn upfield after contact. He gives our quarterbacks a receiver who can earn the first down even when the throw itself falls short of the sticks.
7. Joe DeLamielleure, guard
The Electric Company line made Simpson’s 1973 season possible. DeLamielleure could leave his stance and reach the point where the play was headed instead of merely moving the defender lined up over him. With a back prepared to change direction, gaining position can be more valuable than putting a defender on the ground.
A place for the AFL champions
Billy Shaw gives DeLamielleure a natural counterpart on a pulling line, and Jack Kemp supplies an alternative quarterback for a formation built around power. On defense, the choice after Smith is often between Cornelius Bennett’s range and Darryl Talley’s steadiness. We would take Bennett against a mobile quarterback and Talley when the opponent wants to live in two-tight-end personnel.
An all-time Bills draft roster
Offensive selections QB Josh Allen, RB Thurman Thomas, WRs Andre Reed and Eric Moulds, TE Pete Metzelaars. Build the line around Billy Shaw, Kent Hull and Joe DeLamielleure. Simpson gets the single-back rushing package.
Defensive selections Bruce Smith sets the edge, Kyle Williams attacks inside, Cornelius Bennett plays linebacker. Put Tre’Davious White at corner and George Saimes at safety. Add Darryl Talley against heavier personnel.
Build a 17-0 team in FSN All-Timers
Follow Buffalo Bills coverage on FSN.
Explore all 32 franchise draft boards and FSN’s greatest NFL teams.
