One Indianapolis quarterback used the line of scrimmage as a second huddle. A Baltimore quarterback helped make the two-minute drive an expected part of the sport. This is the Colts’ all-time draft, so both belong. The Baltimore Ravens are a separate history. We rank the Colts years on the player’s own terms, then ask who gets the ball if a defense can change its coverage right up to the snap.
1. Peyton Manning, quarterback
Manning passed for 54,828 yards as a Colt. The advantage began before the throw: he could identify a vulnerable defender, change the protection or turn a run into a pass without bringing a coach back into the conversation. Put familiar route runners on this team and that ability compounds from down to down.
2. Johnny Unitas, quarterback
The tying drive and overtime finish in the 1958 championship game are an excellent introduction to Unitas’ feel for time and distance. He could exploit the middle quickly and keep the offense organized after the catch. Give him the tactical choices available to a contemporary passer and there is no reason to suppose he would stop using the clock as a weapon.
3. Marvin Harrison, wide receiver
Harrison caught 1,102 passes, all with Indianapolis. The extraordinary part of his partnership with Manning was how little either man needed to see before acting. A throw could be in the air before Harrison turned. A slight change of direction could move it away from a safety. He is the first receiver we choose to make the full route tree usable.
4. Gino Marchetti, defensive end
Marchetti could create a difficult pass set for a tackle on his own side and still chase the play across the formation. A modern sack ledger cannot adequately judge the Baltimore defenses of his era. We give him the first defensive spot because he could win at the line without a scheme first removing his blocker.
5. Raymond Berry, wide receiver
Berry’s value increased when the defense knew a pass was coming. Detailed route work and dependable hands gave Unitas a target at the exact depth the down required. Put Berry and Harrison on opposite sides and coordinators have to defend the precision of two entirely different Colts passing systems.
6. Jim Parker, guard and tackle
Parker protected Unitas at left tackle and later excelled at guard. That is valuable flexibility on a small roster, but his place here rests on the quality of each job. He is the first blocker we would take, then settle the other positions around him once we know how the defense plans to rush.
7. Lenny Moore, back and receiver
Moore could run inside or align away from the formation and attack a defensive back. An opponent showing its coverage when he motioned would have given either of our quarterbacks exactly the information he wanted. Edgerrin James has the stronger case for a conventional feature back. Moore earns his place by adding a formation without requiring a substitution.
The best supporting cast for either quarterback
James gained 9,226 rushing yards with Indianapolis and understood Manning’s protection calls. He gets the first carries, with Moore moving around the formation. Reggie Wayne is the first extra receiver. On defense the delicious choice is which side gets Dwight Freeney’s spin move and which gets Robert Mathis chasing the ball from behind. There is no reason to keep either on the bench when the opponent faces third-and-long.
An all-time Colts draft roster
Offensive selections QB Peyton Manning, RB Edgerrin James, WRs Marvin Harrison and Raymond Berry, TE John Mackey. Jim Parker and Quenton Nelson anchor the line. Lenny Moore gives the offense a second back or another receiver from the same personnel.
Defensive selections Gino Marchetti and Dwight Freeney outside, Art Donovan and Tony Siragusa available inside. Ted Hendricks plays linebacker. Bobby Boyd and Lenny Lyles cover outside. Use Robert Mathis as the extra pass rusher.
Build a 17-0 team in FSN All-Timers
Follow Indianapolis Colts coverage on FSN.
Explore all 32 franchise draft boards and FSN’s greatest NFL teams.
