| Rank | Quarterback | School | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Drew Mestemaker | Oklahoma State | 1 |
| 2 | CJ Carr | Notre Dame | 1 |
| 3 | Darian Mensah | Miami | 1 |
| 4 | Dante Moore | Oregon | 2 |
| 5 | Arch Manning | Texas | 2 |
| 6 | Trinidad Chambliss | Ole Miss | 2 |
| 7 | Julian Sayin | Ohio State | 2 |
| 8 | LaNorris Sellers | South Carolina | 3 |
| 9 | Jayden Maiava | USC | 3 |
| 10 | Gunner Stockton | Georgia | 3 |
Drew Mestemaker leads FSN’s 2027 NFL Draft quarterback rankings. The closest call is between CJ Carr and Darian Mensah. If an NFL offense had 90 seconds to go 80 yards, we’d take Carr. If it needed a quarterback to protect a one-score lead over a month of Sundays, Mensah has the best case in the class. Both belong in the first tier.
These are FSN’s grades for potential 2027 entrants, based on games played through November 7. We give the most weight to throws a quarterback can repeat when the first read is covered, the pocket moves or the defense knows a pass is coming. Players in the same tier are close enough that the offense they join could change the order. A ranking here does not establish that a player has entered the draft.
Tier 1 · Three quarterbacks to build a passing game around
Mestemaker gets the edge for the range of throws he can make after moving his feet. Carr has the strongest recent example of running a full-field, two-minute offense. Mensah makes the fewest costly trades between aggression and ball security. Each has shown a way to win that a coordinator can build into a weekly game plan.
1. Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State
Against Kansas State, Mestemaker extended his streak to eight games with at least 300 passing yards and multiple touchdown throws. The reason to put him first is what happens when a defense takes away the spot he wanted to throw from. He can step away, get his feet set again and still reach a receiver breaking across the field. There’s a cost to waiting for that throw. He had eight interceptions through nine games, against two for Mensah. Knowing when to take the short completion is the part of his game that leaves the door open at No. 1. Oklahoma State game report · Team statistics · Scouting Grade film evaluation.
2. CJ Carr, Notre Dame
Start with the drive before halftime against Miami. Notre Dame went 81 yards in 1:39, and Carr finished it with an 18-yard touchdown to Micah Gilbert with 29 seconds left. He completed passes to ten receivers on the night, throwing for 319 yards, three touchdowns and no interceptions. A defense can bracket a favorite target. It’s much harder to protect the whole width of the field against a passer who can find that many answers with the clock running. That game gives Carr the narrow edge over Mensah. Notre Dame’s breakdown · Official scoring summary.
3. Darian Mensah, Miami
Mensah completed 76.8% of his passes for 2,694 yards, 28 touchdowns and two interceptions through nine games. That works out to nearly ten yards per attempt, an important detail for anyone tempted to chalk up the accuracy to easy checkdowns. At Notre Dame, with leading receiver Malachi Toney unavailable, Mensah helped cut a 21-point deficit to seven. His season-long ability to produce big gains without giving away possessions keeps him alongside Carr even after the loss. Miami’s season figures · Miami’s game review.
Tier 2 · Starting upside with an open question
Moore and Sayin have played well enough to challenge the first group, though both have shorter 2026 seasons to evaluate. For Manning and Chambliss, the question is how reliably their best performances translate when a defense changes the terms of the game.
4. Dante Moore, Oregon
Moore threw for 3,565 yards and 30 touchdowns in 2025. The more interesting comparison is his start to this season. After ten interceptions last year, he threw nine touchdowns without an interception in his first 99 attempts. That combination of prior workload and early improvement puts him at the front of this tier. Oregon coach Dan Lanning said on October 26 that he did not expect Moore to play again this season. The missing evidence is whether that improvement would hold over a second full schedule. Oregon’s update on Moore.
5. Arch Manning, Texas
All three of Manning’s touchdown passes at Missouri covered more than 20 yards. He also completed 28 of 38 attempts, so Texas got those explosive plays without spending the rest of the afternoon behind the chains. Across the Longhorns’ three straight wins, he completed 70.5% of his passes. The next question is what he can do when safeties stay deep and a scoring drive requires four or five consecutive throws underneath. That is where Carr and Mensah currently have the stronger case. Texas game and streak figures.
6. Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss
Two Georgia games explain the grade. In January’s Sugar Bowl, Chambliss completed 13 straight passes at one point and finished with 362 yards in a 39–34 win. In the November rematch, Georgia sacked him five times and held him to 170 yards on 34 attempts. The first game shows he can carry an offense against that level of opponent. The second gives a scout a specific set of downs to revisit. When the rush gets home early, how often can he find an outlet and leave his team a manageable third down? Sugar Bowl recap · Georgia’s rematch notes.
7. Julian Sayin, Ohio State
Sayin reached 2,007 yards on 192 attempts, with 19 touchdown passes and four interceptions. That’s more than ten yards an attempt, enough to punish a defense that crowds his short routes. His 15-for-29 game at Indiana also shows how uneven an afternoon can look even when two drives end with touchdown throws. An elbow injury interrupted that game, and Ryan Day said Ohio State was preparing for the possibility that Sayin would miss the rest of the season. His rank reflects how much of this year’s evaluation rests on seven appearances. Ohio State’s Indiana recap · Eleven Warriors’ reporting on Sayin.
Tier 3 · Quarterbacks whose fit matters most
These three would ask different things of an NFL play caller. Sellers gives the running game another ball carrier. Maiava has the passing volume to interest a team that spreads the field. Stockton has shown how much damage he can do when a defense has to honor the run.
8. LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina
With South Carolina protecting a 10–9 lead against Texas A&M, Sellers scored from 41 yards with 1:19 left. That play is why he leads this group. The defense had every reason to play the run and still had to account for one more runner than usual. He also threw for 251 yards that day. To move up a tier, the throws to study are on third-and-long, when a defense can contain him and dare him to beat coverage from the pocket. SEC game recap.
9. Jayden Maiava, USC
Maiava threw 20 touchdowns against five interceptions through nine games. Wisconsin accounted for two of those picks and sacked him five times on a day he attempted 50 passes. That split matters more than his place on a passing-yardage leaderboard. For a team asking him to throw 35 times a week, the question is how many stalled possessions he can rescue once a defense forces USC away from its preferred throws. USC season statistics · Wisconsin box score.
10. Gunner Stockton, Georgia
Stockton beat Ole Miss with four touchdown passes on just nine completions. Two scoring strikes to Talyn Taylor covered 58 and 65 yards. Georgia also ran for 295 yards, which helps explain why the defense had to leave room behind it. A play-action offense should value how quickly Stockton can turn that space into points. Maiava gets the higher spot because there is more evidence of what happens when his offense asks him to throw repeatedly on obvious passing downs. Georgia’s postgame notes.
What the tiers mean for teams picking early
For a team holding multiple first-round picks, the expensive move is trading up past a quarterback it grades just as highly. A club that puts all three leaders in one tier can afford to wait longer than one that sees Mestemaker alone at the top. The Jets make that a real question this spring. Follow the picks they control and where those picks currently fall. Jets 2027 draft picks · 2027 NFL Draft order and traded picks · 2027 NFL Draft top 50 big board · FSN draft hub.
